Border Collie Collars. A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right One

Border Collies are a highly intelligent and extremely energetic dog breed that require a lot of exercise and stimulation.

One very important aspect of owning a Border Collie, is ensuring that they have a suitable collar that is comfortable, high-quality, durable, and secure at the same time.

With so many options available on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one for your pup, so in this article we’ve compiled a list of the top ones we’d recommend, giving you a better idea of which to go for.

Overall, finding the right Border Collie collar is an important decision that can impact your dog’s comfort and safety, so by doing your research and considering your dog’s individual needs, you can find a collar that is both functional and stylish.

Understanding Border Collies

Before we dive into choosing the best collar for Border Collies, it’s important to first look at learning a bit more about the breed, so as to know what to expect.

Veteran owners of Border Collies, might be fine with skipping this part, as they’re more accustomed to the breed already…

For new owners or future owners though, getting to know the breed beforehand, can have huge implications in what types of harnesses, shampoos, crates, collars, and other apparel they end up getting their dog. 

Smart and Energetic

Border Collies are often regarded as the number 1 most smartest dog breed on the planet.

They have a great ability to learn and excel in various activities, such as agility, obedience, and herding.

However, their intelligence also means they need plenty of mental stimulation and exercise to keep them happy and healthy.

Speaking of exercise, they need at least an hour of exercise every day, which could include activities such as running, hiking, or playing fetch.

Herding Needs

As a herding breed, Border Collies have a natural instinct to herd.

They may try to herd other animals, cars, and even children.

For this reason, it’s important to provide them with an outlet for this behavior, such as participating in herding trials, competitions or toys.

Games are also a great option. If you’re looking for specific games for Border Collies, we’ve made an article on games, here. 

Curious Nature

Border Collies are known for their curious nature and love to explore their surroundings.

They have a strong desire to investigate and learn about their environment.

This curiosity can sometimes lead them into trouble, so it’s important to keep a close eye on them and provide plenty of mental stimulation.

All in all, Border Collies are extremely active.

They’re a smart, energetic breed that requires plenty of exercise and mental stimulation.

They’ll be highly active throughout the day, and depending on the dog of course, may need more or less exercise, but generally speaking, they’ll be moving around quite a bit.

They’re also pretty athletic and strong, which is something to keep in mind when choosing a collar too. You’ll want to choose one that is durable, resistant, relatively inexpensive and that won’t harm the skin.

With this out of the way, let’s now look at some of the top collars for Border Collies.

Choosing the Right Collar for Your Border Collie

Choosing the right collar, is important.

They serve multiple purposes beyond just holding identification tags, like a means for control, training, and a fashion expression (to a lesser extent).

With that said, each Border Collie is unique and their collar should reflect their individual needs and behaviors.

Factors to Consider When Selecting a Collar

When looking for a Border Collie collar, it’s important to consider factors such as:

Size and Fit 

A collar that’s too tight can be uncomfortable and potentially harmful, while a loose collar risks slipping off.

Measure your Collie’s neck size accurately and choose an adjustable collar for growth.

Material

Collars come in a variety of materials, including leather, nylon, and neoprene, and can feature different closures such as buckles or quick-release clips.

In terms of material, nylon webbing is a popular choice for Border Collie collars.

It’s strong, durable, and lightweight, making it perfect for active dogs.

Leather is another option, but it can be heavier and may require more maintenance.

When choosing a collar for your Border Collie, take into consideration your dog’s skin sensitivity, activity level, and durability requirements.

Training Needs

Depending on your training requirements or your specific situation, you might need a completely different set of collars.

We won’t be going over these in too much detail in this article, as they’re specific and most owners won’t be using them.

But to briefly mention these, they include:

Shock Collars And Anti Barking Collars 

Shock collars and anti barking collars, are controversial and should only be used in specific situations.

These collars deliver a mild electric shock to the dog’s neck when they misbehave or start to bark excessively.

Their design looks to enhance corrections during training, but their use requires a deep understanding of canine behavior and proper handling techniques.

NOTE: If you are considering a shock collar, make sure you do your research and consult with a professional trainer before using one.

Usually, positive reinforcement techniques are enough to correct behaviors, and there’s no need to hurt the dog.

GPS Tracking Collars

Other special collars, such as GPS tracking collars, track your pet’s location real-time and proves to be pretty invaluable in situations where a pet has strayed away or gotten lost.

Step-by-Step Guide to Finding the Perfect Collar

In this section, we’ll be going over the step-by-step process to choosing the perfect collar for your Border Collie dog.

Step 1: Measure Your Border Collie’s Neck Size

The first and most important step of the process, is making that the collar that you’ll get, fits properly and is not too tight or too loose.

To measure your dog’s neck, use a soft measuring tape and add two inches to the measurement. This will give you the correct size for your dog’s collar size.

Step 2: Consider Your Collie’s Behavior and Needs

As we mentioned throughout this article, each Border Collie is different, so you’ll want to assess your dog’s behavior during walks and other activities.

Do they pull strongly or walk calmly?

• If your Collie is a puller, consider a collar designed to discourage pulling. A harness can be a good alternative for those who pull excessively.
• If they are well-behaved on walks, a standard flat collar might be suitable, and will generally last a long time.

Step 3: Choose the Type of Collar

• Martingale Collars: If your Collie tends to slip out of traditional collars, a martingale collar can provide better control without choking.
• Harnesses: If your Collie pulls on the leash, consider a front-clip harness that distributes pressure evenly instead.
• Flat Collars: For well-behaved Collies, a flat collar provides a simple and comfortable option.

Step 4: Select a Suitable Material

The material you choose for the collar, should align with your Collie’s specific needs, activity level, and skin sensitivity.

When it comes to materials, you have:

• Nylon collars: They’re lightweight, affordable, and resistant to water and wear, making them suitable for active Collies. However, they might cause irritation to sensitive skin and can sometimes lack the durability of other materials.
• Leather collars: These have a classic look to them, offer durability, and tend to age well. Nevertheless, leather can be relatively expensive, and it might require regular maintenance to prevent cracking or discoloration due to exposure to moisture.
• Fabric collars: These collars offer endless design options, allowing you to showcase your Collie’s personality, and they are generally softer on the skin. Keep in mind that they’re not as durable as nylon or leather and can fray over time, particularly with active dogs.

Step 5: Reflective or LED Collars for Nighttime Visibility

If you often walk your Collie in low-light conditions or at night, consider a collar with reflective strips or LED lights to enhance visibility.

Step 6: Check Online Reviews and Recommendations

Before committing to buying any sort of collar, make sure to research online for reviews and recommendations from other Border Collie owners, on these specific items.

This will help you save time and money, and have you be confident in choosing an option that has been market tested.

Step 7: Purchase and Monitor

Based on your research and assessment, make the purchase.

Once you have the collar, closely monitor your Collie’s reaction during the first few days of wear.

Most collars can be returned if you’re unhappy with them, so this should not be a life-ending purchase, by any means. 

Top Border Collie Collars: 

Now that we’ve gone over all that information, it’s time to look at some of the top Border Collie collars available, in a bit more detail.

We’ll be looking at specific brands, features, prices, pros and cons, and we’ll be recommending our top choice from a cost-effectiveness and quality standpoint, based on information gathered at the very end.

Ruffwear Front Range Dog Collar

The Ruffwear Front Range Dog Collar is designed for everyday adventures.

It features an aluminum V-ring leash attachment and a separate ID tag attachment point, keeping your Collie safe and stylish.

The collar comes with a silicone tag silencer to minimize jingling, too.

Materials: Made from durable nylon webbing, the Ruffwear Front Range Collar is both tough and comfortable.

Pros: Sturdy construction, reflective trim for visibility, multiple color options.

Cons: Sizing can be a bit too big for most dogs, and they’re relatively on the higher price point.

Price: $19.95

Auburn Lake Country Leather Martingale Collar

The Auburn Lake Country Leather Martingale Collar combines classic style with effective training features.

Designed to prevent escape and discourage pulling, this collar offers a balance between control and comfort. It features a limited-slip design that tightens gently when tension is applied.

Materials: Crafted from genuine leather for durability and a timeless look.

Pros: Elegant design, suitable for training, prevents slipping out.

Cons: Leather may require maintenance, limited color options and pretty expensive.

Price: $46.00 to $56.00

Blueberry Pet Classic Dog Collar

The Blueberry Pet Classic Dog Collar offers a blend of style and functionality.

With its durable D-ring for leash attachment and adjustable strap, this collar is perfect for daily walks and training sessions.

Materials: High-density polyester webbing ensures durability while providing a soft touch.

Pros: Wide range of colors and designs, cost-effective, machine washable.

Cons: Not suitable for heavy pullers, limited width options.

Price: $10.99

Coastal Pet New Earth Soy Dog Collar

The Coastal Pet New Earth Soy Dog Collar is not only eco-friendly but also durable. The collar comes with a buckle made from recycled materials and a D-ring for leash attachment.

Crafted from soy fibers, it offers a soft and comfortable fit for your Border Collie.

Materials: The collar is made out of soy fibers, which makes it an environmentally conscious choice.

Pros: Eco-friendly, soft and comfortable, available in various earthy tones.

Cons: Limited adjustability, not suitable for heavy pullers.

Price: $9.95

LupinePet Eco Dog Collar

The LupinePet Eco Dog Collar is designed for both style and sustainability.

It features a unique side-release buckle for ease of use and a welded steel D-ring for leash attachment.

This collar is also backed by LupinePet’s “Even If Chewed” guarantee.

Materials: Made from recycled plastic bottles, making it eco-friendly and durable.

Pros: Vibrant patterns, backed by a guarantee, available in multiple sizes.

Cons: May not be suitable for strong pullers, and slightly higher price point in comparison to most options.

Price: from $10.49 to $38.98

Hamilton Reflective Dog Collar

The Hamilton Reflective Dog Collar focuses on safety and visibility. It comes with reflective stitching that enhances visibility during nighttime walks.

The adjustable collar is designed for comfort and easy attachment of tags and leashes.

Materials: Crafted from durable nylon with reflective stitching for added safety.

Pros: High visibility, affordable, suitable for all sizes.

Cons: Basic design, may not withstand heavy pulling and has a relatively higher price point.

Price: $26.99

Max and Neo Nylon Martingale Collar

The Max and Neo Nylon Martingale Collar is designed for dogs that tend to pull and slip out of traditional collars.

The martingale design provides gentle correction and prevents escape without choking.

Materials: Made from heavy-duty nylon for durability.

Pros: Prevents slipping out, suitable for training, lifetime warranty.

Cons: Limited color options, requires correct sizing for effective use.

Price: $15.99

PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar

The PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar offers an alternative approach to walking by gently guiding your Border Collie’s head.

It reduces pulling and provides control without choking, making walks more enjoyable.

Materials: Constructed from soft nylon that fits comfortably over the nose.

Pros: Reduces pulling, adjustable fit, includes training DVD.

Cons: Requires training for proper use, may take time for dogs to adjust, and is on the more expensive side.

Price: $19.95

Training Tips for Introducing a New Collar

Getting used to a new collar, can be tough for any dog. Here are some tips for you to take into account, when introducing your dog to a new collar:

• Positive Association: Treats and Rewards: Associate the new collar with positive experiences by giving treats and praise when your Collie wears it. This creates a positive connection.
• Gradual Introduction and Desensitization: Your Collie might be initially apprehensive about the new collar. Gradually introduce it, allowing them to sniff and investigate. Avoid rushing the process.
• Initial Supervised Wear and Monitoring: During the first few days, supervise your Collie while they wear it. Monitor for any signs of discomfort, irritation, or attempts to remove it.

Maintaining the Collar for Longevity

As for maintaining the longevity of your collar, you’ll want to:

• Regularly clean the collar. Collars can accumulate dirt and bacteria. Regularly clean the collar according to the manufacturer’s instructions to ensure hygiene and longevity.
• Checking for Wear and Tear. Inspect the collar for signs of wear, such as frayed edges or damaged buckles. If it shows too much wear, it might be time to change it. to prevent accidents.

Border Collie Collars Conclusion

After looking the top collars for Border Collies based on their materials, features, costs, pros, and cons, our number one recommended option for best choice, is the Auburn Lake Country Leather Martingale Collar.

While it might have a slightly higher price point compared to some other options, its combination of elegance, durability, and training functionality make it a solid investment.

Elegance and Durability: The Auburn Lake Country Collar is meticulously crafted from premium leather, ensuring not only enduring durability but also a dignified appearance.

Precision Training with Martingale Functionality: Training a Border Collie requires a collar that strikes the perfect balance between control and comfort, and this collar design offers precisely that. It provides gentle correction during training, preventing escape and discouraging pulling.

Quality over Quantity: While it’s true that the collar offers minimal color options, the emphasis here lies in quality over quantity. Each Auburn Lake Country Collar is a testament to skilled artistry and meticulous attention to detail. 

Despite needing regular maintenance to preserve its quality, the Leather Martingale Collar’s benefits far outweigh its drawbacks, ensuring the safety and comfort of your beloved Border Collie and it’s natural materials don’t cause any rashes or skin itches.

In the end, the choice of collar depends on your specific needs, preferences, and your Border Collie’s behavior.

Whether you opt for the affordability of nylon, the durability of leather, or the functionality of a training collar, the most important aspect is choosing a collar that keeps your Border Collie safe and happy during all your adventures together.